Working paper 3.0 · exploratory policy framework · not enacted lawSupport this work

Research landscape

Election integrity, eligibility, and restricted participation

The United States already treats noncitizen voting in federal elections as illegal. Current legislative debate is centered on whether to add documentary proof-of-citizenship at registration, not on whether citizenship is required in principle. The most robust causal evidence retrieved is adjacent rather than direct: studies of strict photo-ID laws, not of registration-time proof-of-citizenship itself.

Documentary proof-of-citizenship

The SAVE America Act is described as proposed federal legislation that would require documentary proof of U.S. citizenship (passport, birth certificate, naturalization certificate, or similar) for federal voter registration. As of mid-2026 it had passed the U.S. House but had not become law. There is no retrieved DPOC-specific causal estimate for registration, turnout, or implementation burden comparable to the best-known strict-ID studies.

GAO found that most registered voters in reviewed ID-ownership studies had qualifying IDs, but that direct costs varied and underlying-document requirements mattered: free IDs could still require supporting documents such as birth certificates, which cost money in many states. DPOC proposals move that burden earlier, onto registration.

Strict ID: a methodological dispute

Contested GAO (2014), using a selected-state quasi-experiment, estimated turnout declines of roughly 1.9-2.2 percentage points in Kansas and 2.2-3.2 points in Tennessee after stricter ID changes, with larger reductions for younger, newer, and African-American registrants. GAO is explicit that its results are not generalizable beyond those states.

Cantoni and Pons (2021) use a nationwide administrative panel with voter fixed effects and find no negative average effect on registration or turnout overall or by race, gender, age, or party, and no detectable effect on reported fraud or perceived election fairness in their preferred specifications. They explicitly describe an earlier literature running from negative effects to null findings.

Public opinion

Pew finds broad support for paper-ballot backups and photo ID, but sharp partisan splits over vote-by-mail, automatic registration, and Election Day registration. Support for photo ID is 81% overall, with 95% of Republicans and 69% of Democrats favoring it in the January 2024 Pew survey. Americans do not line up neatly into “access” versus “integrity” camps.

Compulsory or quasi-compulsory voting

Evidence gap In the retrieved materials, compulsory voting appears as a comparative reference point (Australia and Belgium, civil penalties rather than criminal punishment) or as an exploratory proposal, not as a policy that currently operates in a U.S. jurisdiction at general scale. The $2,000 civil fine in this framework is a design parameter, not a domestic causal estimate.

De facto layered engagement

The strongest U.S. analogue to tiered participation is not a formal legal class but a pattern of de facto layered engagement: 2024 presidential turnout around 64-65%; 26% of adult citizens voting in none of the last three national elections; sizable shares who vote in presidential years but skip midterms. Formal tiering is a proposal. Episodic nonvoting and chronic abstention are observed facts.

Most useful sources to read first

  1. GAO (2014), Issues Related to State Voter Identification Laws: selected-state quasi-experiment and administrative-burden evidence.
  2. Cantoni and Pons (2021), NBER: nationwide administrative panel; null average effects.
  3. Pew Research Center (2024): public-opinion benchmark for restrictive versus expansive rules.

Election-integrity proposal · Disengagement research · Electorate brief

Commentary

Semi-public notes for this page. In this preview they stay in your browser. A hosted edition would use moderated public threads.

  • No public notes yet. Be the first to leave a careful comment.