Working paper 3.0 · exploratory policy framework · not enacted lawSupport this work

Research landscape

Entitlement reform via voluntary self-selection

The federal baseline is dominated by Social Security and Medicare. Any opt-out or buyout analysis that excludes the old-age programs will miss the largest federal liability pool. The biggest empirical gap is the one this concept most needs: there is no retrieved federal or peer-reviewed U.S. study that estimates how many younger adults would voluntarily opt out of traditional Social Security and Medicare in exchange for a one-time buyout plus a simplified support track.

OASI depletion
2033

2025 Trustees; 77% payable

Combined OASDI
2034

81% payable at depletion

OASDI 75-year gap
3.82%

Share of taxable payroll

Medicare Advantage
50-55%

Part C share, 2024-26

Baseline programs

ProgramLatest verified scaleSolvency marker
Social Security OASI2024 cost $1,327.2B; 60.1M beneficiaries; admin 0.4%Depletion 2033; 75-year balance −3.95% of payroll
Social Security DI2024 cost $157.6B; 8.3M beneficiariesProjected solvent through at least 2099
Medicare total2024 expenditure $1,122.1B; 67.6M beneficiariesHI depletion 2033; 89% payable; HI gap 0.42% of payroll
SNAPFY2024 cost $99.8B; 41.7M average monthly participantsNot a long-run trust-fund problem of the same type
EITCTY2024: about 24M claims totaling about $69.6BUseful as a UBI-offset candidate, not a solvency analogue

CBO’s FY2025 budget infographic says mandatory outlays were $4.2T in 2025 and that Social Security and Medicare accounted for the majority of mandatory spending and more than one-third of all federal spending.

Cash-transfer evidence

Stockton SEED: treatment-group monthly income volatility was 46.4% versus 67.5% for controls; ability to cover an unexpected expense with cash rose from 25% to 52% among recipients versus 25% to 28% in the control group. Peer-reviewed evaluation reported that guaranteed income did not cause labor-force exit and improved physical and psychological health during the pandemic period. The pilot paid $500/month to 131 residents.

Finland’s 2017-2018 experiment paid €560/month to 2,000 unemployed persons aged 25-58. Employment effect was small (about 6 extra days worked); recipients reported better life satisfaction and economic security. The treatment group was limited to unemployed recipients, not the full population.

Evidence gap The Alaska Permanent Fund Dividend is an important U.S. analogue; a dedicated quantitative labor-supply pull was not completed in this pass.

Work incentives and cliffs

The strongest “work incentives” evidence is about means-tested phase-outs, not about large unconditional-cash work collapse. NBER estimates that over half of working-age Americans face lifetime marginal net tax rates above 40%; one quarter of bottom-quintile households face rates above 50%; one in ten above 70%. ASPE reports a median effective marginal tax rate of 51% for households with children just above poverty. Recipients also weigh the risk of losing benefits and the difficulty of getting them back.

Medicare Advantage as a choice analogue

About 50% of Medicare beneficiaries were in private Part C plans in 2024; 55% of eligible beneficiaries are enrolled in 2026. MedPAC/KFF estimate that 2025 payments to MA plans were 20% above comparable traditional Medicare spending, adding about $84 billion. Brookings summarizes current favorable selection into MA at an estimated 11% in 2025.

UBI cost template

A 2026 Basic Income Studies article estimates that a UBI set at $16,000 per adult and $8,000 per child, with a 50% marginal tax rate, would have a net cost of about $783.7B per year, or about 2.67% of GDP, in 2024. That paper is a poverty-line UBI estimate rather than an integrated replacement design. UBI parameters in this framework remain unset pending actuarial review.

What is still missing

  • No direct U.S. evidence on whole-regime self-selection between Social Security/Medicare and a UBI/buyout track.
  • Weak evidence on fertility or retirement-timing response to permanent unconditional cash.
  • Incomplete extraction in this pass for SSI, CTC, housing assistance, and Medicaid totals.
  • No formal nationwide UBI administrative-overhead estimate.

Entitlement proposal · Regular Citizen brief · Debt research

Commentary

Semi-public notes for this page. In this preview they stay in your browser. A hosted edition would use moderated public threads.

  • No public notes yet. Be the first to leave a careful comment.